The personite problem
WebbBut as I discuss in this talk, relating to contemporary discussions in metaontology, this response for principled reasons doesn’t work. The problems I discuss illustrate the significance of metaontological considerations for issues in ethics and metaethics, and generalize widely beyond the personite problem.
The personite problem
Did you know?
WebbFor every person, there are countless personites. It seems that if persons matter, then so do personites. But this raises serious challenges to ordinary mora... Webb1 dec. 2016 · The problem, he argues, is that such theories are committed to the existence of personites, shorter-lived objects coincident with people; that personites have moral status on any plausible theory...
WebbCall this the absurd result. Mark’s argument that four-dimensionalism leads to the absurd result goes as follows. On four-dimensionalism, there is a “personite” who is a temporal part of Mark and who exists just during the agonizing month of May in which he learns Hungarian. Call this personite Shorty. WebbPersonites are shorter-lived, person-like things that extend across part of a person’s life. Their existence follows from the standard perdurance view of persons. Johnston argues …
WebbThe Explanatory Problem for Cognitivism About Practical Reason. Errol Lord - forthcoming - In Conor McHugh Jonathan Way & Daniel Whiting (eds.), Normativity: Epistemic and Practical. Practical Reason, Instrumental Irrationality, and Time. Manuel Vargas - 2005 - Philosophical Studies 126 (2):241-252. Webb1 apr. 2024 · I show that the personite problem can be reworked as an argument against stage theorists. The stage theorist can respond by rejecting an assumption of the …
Webbdetails. Mark Johnston and Eric Olson have both pressed what Johnston has dubbed the personite problem. Personites, if they exist, are person-like entities whose lives extend over a continuous proper part of a person’s life. They are so person-like that they seem to have moral status if persons do.
Webb1 sep. 2024 · According to the worm theory, persons are (maximal) aggregates of person-stages existing at different times. Personites, on the other hand, are non-maximal … port angeles washington storesWebbMark Johnston and Eric Olson have both pressed what Johnston has dubbed the personite problem. Personites, if they exist, are person-like entities whose lives extend over a continuous proper part o ... irish meals to cookWebb12 nov. 2024 · Stage theory and the personite problem. Mark Johnston has recently argued that fourdimensionalist theories of persistence are incompatible with some of our most basic ethical and prudential principles. I argue that although Johnston’s arguments succeed on a wormtheoretic account of persistence, they fail on a stage-theoretic account. irish meals for dinnerWebbThe Explanatory Problem for Cognitivism about Practical Reason. Errol Lord - forthcoming - In Conor McHugh Jonathan Way & Daniel Whiting (eds.), Normativity: Epistemic and … irish meaning of erinWebbThe Explanatory Problem for Cognitivism About Practical Reason. Errol Lord - forthcoming - In Conor McHugh Jonathan Way & Daniel Whiting (eds.), Normativity: Epistemic and … irish meals near meWebbdubbed the personite problem. Personites, if they exist, are person-like entities whose lives extend over a continuous proper part of a person’s life. They are so person-like that they … irish meals not corned beefWebbMark Johnston and Eric Olson have both pressed what Johnston has dubbed the personite problem. Personites, if they exist, are person-like entities whose lives extend over a … port angeles washington brewery